After the collective "feh" that most people sighed in reaction to this year's tepid Oscar show, there remain a couple of moments that linger as highlights between James Franco's smug slouch and Anne Hathaway's fretful zeal. The King's Speech preordained wins were not among them, but the thoughtful, moving speeches given by star Colin Firth, director Tom Hooper, and screenwriter David Seidler that stood in contrast to the graceless, boring, "bad TV" moments of so many other honorees certainly were. There's been a lot of grousing about how The King's inevitable coronation insidiously seeped into many aspects of the show, especially the final Best Picture montage. But one royal reference that was also among the shows standout moments was when Helen Mirren and Russell Brand appeared to award the Best Foreign Language Film. Deadpan, elegant, and in perfectly accented French, Dame Helen announced the award category, and then paused for translation from her unlikely pal and upcoming co-star in the Arthur remake: "What Helen said was, ‘Yo, my Oscar winning performance as a Queen was much more realistic than Colin Firth's as a King.'"
Whether or not that's so, it's true that Oscar loves royalty. Add that to the fact that an actor's skill in portraying and overcoming a disability gives the Academy an even deeper glow, any doubt that The King's Speech would walk away with quad top honors of Picture, Actor, Director, and Screenplay should have surprised no one. And hey, it didn't!
As anecdotal evidence of Oscar's penchant for the Crown, here's a list of some other notable wins and nominations that have tickled Academy voting fingers over the years:
The Queen (2006): Helen Mirren was a pretty obvious choice by any standard when she won Best Actress for her portrayal of Queen Elizabeth II, a modern monarch with chilly warmth and a palpable struggle that kept her loyalties divided between family and country. She was in good company with co-nominees Meryl Streep, Kate Winslet, Penelope Cruz, and Judi Dench (more about her later). It was also not Dame Helen's first nomination for playing the Queen of England. She was in the Best Supporting Actress category in 1995 for The Madness of King George (more about that later too). Hers was the only win for The Queen, though it was also nominated for Best Picture, Director (Stephen Frears), Original Screenplay (Peter Morgan), Score (Alexandre Desplat), and Costume Design.
Elizabeth (1998) and Elizabeth: The Golden Age: (2007): Cate Blanchett was twice nominated for her decade-apart portrayals of the icy, beautiful, Queen Elizabeth I, but was trumped the first time by non-Queen Gwyneth Paltrow for Shakespeare in Love (more later again), then by Marion Cotillard for La Vie En Rose. In addition to several art and technical nominations, Elizabeth was one of the Best Picture entries at 1999's Oscar show (it earned four other nominations, winning only for Best Makeup), but Elizabeth: The Golden Age was shut out of all other categories in 2008 except Costume Design, although it did win that category. Cate Blanchett does have an Oscar statuette on her mantel, having won Best Supporting Actress in 2005 for The Aviator. She also received Supporting Actress noms in 2007 for Notes on a Scandal, and in 2008 for I'm Not There (in competition with herself for the Elizabeth Best Actress performance!).
Shakespeare in Love (1998): In addition to darling Gwynnie's win, Dame Judi Dench took home a Best Supporting Actress Oscar for playing a similarly wintry Elizabeth II (was she better than Cate Blanchett? Hmmm…). The movie that the Academy adorned with 13 nominations took home five others, including Best Picture. It beat heavy favorite Saving Private Ryan in that top category, but at least Steven Spielberg took home the Best Director statuette so he could bonk Shakespeare director John Madden over the head with it.
Her Majesty, Mrs. Brown (1997): Speaking of Judi Dench, her role as a curmudgeonly Queen Victoria gained her a Best Actress nomination, but she was aced at 1998's Oscar show by Helen Hunt for As Good As It Gets. Dame Judi has since been honored with Supporting Actress nominations for Chocolat (2000), and Leading Actress nominations for Iris (2001), Mrs. Henderson Presents (2005), and Notes on a Scandal (2006).
The Madness of King George (1994): The great Nigel Hawthorne reprised his original stage performance in Alan Bennett's adaptation of his play The Madness of George III, and rightly earned himself a Best Actor Nomination for portraying the monarch who lost the American colonies, then went completely loony. Speculation is that the madness was caused by the disease porphyria, while Hawthorne's Oscar loss was most definitely blamed on a shameless win by Tom Hanks for Forrest Gump. The Madness of King George did take home an Oscar for Art Direction-Set Decoration, and Alan Bennett was nominated for his Adapted Screenplay. As mentioned above, Helen Mirren earned a Supporting Actress nomination as George's devoted Queen Charlotte.
The Lion in Winter (1968): Katharine Hepburn won Best Actress honors (in a rare tie, with Barbra Streisand for Funny Girl) for her portrayal of Eleanor of Aquitaine, who married Henry II and became Queen of the English in a rather roundabout way. It was a consecutive win for Hepburn after having taken home the Oscar the previous year for Guess Who's Coming to Dinner? It represented another milestone in that Katharine Hepburn still holds the record for multiple lead acting Oscar wins -- she also received Best Actress honors for one of her first roles in Morning Glory (1931), and for one of her last in On Golden Pond (1981). As for the Lion himself, Peter O'Toole was nominated, but lost that year to Cliff Robertson for Charly.
A Man For All Seasons (1966): The Academy really loved this rousing adaptation of Robert Bolt's play, and it took home six Oscars in 1967, including Best Picture, Best Director (Fred Zinnemann), Best Adapted screenplay (Bolt), Cinematography, and Costume Design. Paul Scofield won as Best Actor for playing Sir Thomas More, the Chancellor of England who denied King Henry VIII a divorce from Catherine of Aragon and lost his head for it. A youngish Robert Shaw, nominated in the Supporting category for playing the King kept his head, but lost the Oscar to Walter Mathau for The Fortune Cookie.
A few more films with Royal themes that Oscar loved a little bit include Mary Queen of Scots (1971), which earned Vanessa Redgrave one of her five nominations (she won as Supporting Actress in 1978 for Julia), and Anne of the Thousand Days (1969), which got nominations for Best Picture, Best Actor (Richard Burton), Best Actress (Geneviève Bujold), and Best Supporting Actor (Anthony Quayle), among its 10, but won only for Costume Design. The Young Victoria (2009) also won for Costume Design, but was not recognized for a fine performance by Emily Blunt as the Queen who would much later achieve lasting fame for loosing a sexy secret in the retail sales arena. The beautiful Emily Blunt may yet have a chance, for playing British royalty clearly plays to Oscar's weakness, especially if there's a pretty face and/or a stumbling speech involved.--Ted Fry